Fantasy Island Resturant & Bar Menu (Updated 2026)

Fantasy Island Restaurant & Bar features a menu centered on Caribbean cuisine with a focus on hearty entrees and shareable plates. The menu is structured into several key categories including Caribbean meals, specialty items, pizzas, and sides. The Caribbean meals section highlights options such as chicken wings available in multiple portion sizes with fries, chicken tenders, shrimp, burgers, and sandwiches, offering a range of casual dining choices priced mostly under $15. A pizza selection includes mini options as well as large cheese and specialty pizzas like pepperoni and supreme at moderate prices.

The signature Fritay's section presents traditional Caribbean dishes such as Griot, Goat, Fish, Oxtail, Chicken, and Turkey, with prices ranging from $38 to $46, reflecting larger, more substantial entrées. Complementary sides include staple Caribbean accompaniments like rice, plantain, cabbage, as well as fries, onion rings, and fried okra, all priced under $5. Overall, the menu balances casual snacks and shareable items with more elaborate main dishes, maintaining an average price range between $20 and $30 for most offerings.

The menu features a strong emphasis on Caribbean-style protein dishes, with wings and Fritay meals like Griot and Oxtail serving as signature options. Budget-friendly choices are available in the Fantasy Caribbean Meals section, where smaller portions like 3-piece tenders and mini pizzas are priced under $10, while large orders and specialty Fritay dishes exceed $35, reflecting premium pricing. Sides such as fries, plantain, and cabbage offer moderately priced additions between $3.75 and $4.25, suitable for complementing main dishes. The variety in portion sizes suggests flexibility for both casual snacking and full meals, though no distinct time-of-day segmentation is indicated in the menu data.